* ICSE 2018 *
Sun 27 May - Sun 3 June 2018 Gothenburg, Sweden
Fri 1 Jun 2018 11:00 - 11:15 at R2 - Empirical Studies and Requirements Chair(s): Julia Lawall

Context: There is growing interest in establishing software engineering as an evidence-based discipline. To that end, replication is often used to gain confidence in empirical findings, as opposed to reproduction where the goal is showing the correctness, or validity of the published results.

Objective: To consider what is required for a replication study to confirm the original experiment and apply this understanding in software engineering.

Method: Simulation is used to demonstrate why the prediction interval for confirmation can be surprisingly wide. This analysis is applied to three recent replications.

Results: It is shown that because the prediction intervals are wide, almost all replications are confirmatory, so in that sense there is no ‘replication crisis’, however, the contributions to knowledge are negligible.

Conclusion: Replicating empirical software engineering experiments, particularly if they are under-powered or under-reported, is a waste of scientific resources. By contrast, meta-analysis is strongly advocated so that all relevant experiments are combined to estimate the population effect.

Fri 1 Jun

icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results
11:00 - 12:30: NIER - New Ideas and Emerging Results - Empirical Studies and Requirements at R2
Chair(s): Julia LawallInria/LIP6
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results11:00 - 11:15
Talk
Martin ShepperdBrunel University London
DOI Pre-print
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results11:15 - 11:30
Talk
Matthias GalsterUniversity of Canterbury, Danny WeynsKU Leuven, Antony TangSwinburne University of Technology, Rick Kazman, Mehdi MirakhorliRochester Institute of Technology
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results11:30 - 11:45
Talk
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results11:45 - 12:00
Talk
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results12:00 - 12:15
Talk
icse-2018-New-Ideas-and-Emerging-Results12:15 - 12:30
Talk
Mahnaz BehrooziNCSU, Alison Lui, Ian Moore, Denae FordNorth Carolina State University, Chris ParninNCSU
Pre-print