* ICSE 2018 *
Sun 27 May - Sun 3 June 2018 Gothenburg, Sweden
Thu 31 May 2018 11:40 - 12:00 at H1 room - Communities and Ecosystems Chair(s): Alexander Serebrenik

Modern code reviews improve the quality of software products. Although modern code reviews rely heavily on human interactions, little is known regarding whether they are performed fairly. Fairness plays a role in any process where decisions that affect others are made. When a system is perceived to be unfair, it affects negatively the productivity and motivation of its participants.

In this paper, using fairness theory we create a framework that describes how fairness affects modern code reviews. To demonstrate its applicability, and the importance of fairness in code reviews, we conducted an empirical study that asked developers of a large industrial open source ecosystem (OpenStack) what their perceptions are regarding fairness in their code reviewing process. Our study shows that, in general, the code review process in OpenStack is perceived as fair; however, a significant portion of respondents perceive it as unfair. We also show that the variability in the way they prioritize code reviews signals a lack of consistency and the existence of bias (potentially increasing the perception of unfairness).

The contributions of this paper are: we propose a framework—based on fairness theory—for studying and managing social behaviour in modern code reviews, we provide support for the framework through the results of a case study on a large industrial-backed open source project, we present evidence that fairness is an issue in the code review process of a large open source ecosystem, and, we present a set of guidelines for practitioners to address unfairness in modern code reviews.

Thu 31 May

icse-2018-Technical-Papers
11:00 - 12:30: Technical Papers - Communities and Ecosystems at H1 room
Chair(s): Alexander SerebrenikEindhoven University of Technology
icse-2018-Technical-Papers152775720000011:00 - 11:20
Talk
Mauricio AnicheDelft University of Technology, Netherlands, Christoph TreudeThe University of Adelaide, Igor SteinmacherFederal University of Technology - Paraná / Northern Arizona University, Igor WieseFederal University of Technology - Paraná (UTFPR), Gustavo PintoUFPA, Margaret-Anne StoreyUniversity of Victoria, Marco GerosaNorthern Arizona University
Pre-print
icse-2018-Technical-Papers152775840000011:20 - 11:40
Talk
Asher TrockmanUniversity of Evansville, Shurui ZhouCarnegie Mellon University, USA, Christian KästnerCarnegie Mellon University, Bogdan VasilescuCarnegie Mellon University
Pre-print Media Attached
icse-2018-Technical-Papers152775960000011:40 - 12:00
Talk
Daniel M. German, Gregorio RoblesUniversidad Rey Juan Carlos, Germán Poo-Caamaño, Xin YangUnionbigdata.com, Hajimu Iida, Katsuro InoueOsaka University
Pre-print File Attached
icse-2018-Journal-first-papers152776080000012:00 - 12:20
Talk
Mirco FranzagoUniversity of L'Aquila, Italy, Ivano MalavoltaVrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Davide Di RuscioUniversity of L'Aquila, Henry MucciniUniversity of L'Aquila
Link to publication DOI Pre-print
icse-2018-Technical-Papers152776200000012:20 - 12:30
Talk